Toll Brothers in St. Johns County
Toll Brothers brings a luxury-first approach to new construction in St. Johns County, with larger floor plans, elevated finishes, and design options that feel a step above typical production builders. If you want polished model-home style with real customization, this is one of the most recognized builder names in the market.
Want to compare notes with the builder’s official information first? Browse the official Toll Brothers site.
Builder Overview
Toll Brothers was founded in 1967 and has grown into one of the best-known luxury homebuilders in the country. The company is publicly traded on the New York Stock Exchange under the ticker symbol TOL, and its Florida footprint stretches from Northeast Florida down through Central and South Florida. In this market, Toll Brothers usually competes for buyers who want a more upscale build experience than the typical entry-level or move-up production option.
What separates Toll Brothers is not just the brand name. Their plans in St. Johns County tend to emphasize taller ceilings, more dramatic entries, premium kitchen layouts, larger outdoor living spaces, and stronger personalization during the build process. Buyers can often choose structural changes, cabinetry, flooring, lighting, appliance packages, and other finish selections through the company’s design process, which is a major reason the builder attracts luxury-minded shoppers.
In Florida, Toll Brothers has built a strong presence in master-planned communities and higher-end infill locations where buyers want newer construction without giving up architecture, curb appeal, or a refined interior package. In St. Johns County specifically, the builder’s lineup leans heavily toward upper-tier single-family homes, with a few lower-maintenance product types mixed in depending on the neighborhood.
Communities in St. Johns County
Toll Brothers’ St. Johns County presence is spread across several distinct submarkets, from Ponte Vedra-area luxury communities to master-planned neighborhoods around St. Augustine and RiverTown. Inventory and phases change, but these are the communities buyers most often see on Toll Brothers’ current St. Johns County lineup.
Bartram Ranch
Bartram Ranch is one of Toll Brothers’ more attainable entry points in St. Johns County, but it still skews larger and more upgraded than many competing production options. Expect spacious single-family plans with room for flexible living areas, larger kitchens, and outdoor entertaining space.
- Approx. 2,447–4,474 sq. ft.
- Single-family homes
- Good fit for buyers who want size without jumping to the top of the market
Estuary at Madeira
Estuary at Madeira puts Toll Brothers in a polished St. Augustine setting where buyers can get a luxury single-family home with a more coastal feel. This is the kind of community shoppers consider when they want upgraded finishes and generous square footage without going all the way into ultra-premium Ponte Vedra pricing.
- Approx. 2,905–4,144 sq. ft.
- Single-family homes
- Popular for buyers wanting newer luxury inventory closer to St. Augustine
Haven at Palm Valley
Haven at Palm Valley is aimed squarely at the higher end of the St. Johns County market. Buyers looking in this segment are usually prioritizing location, architecture, and a stronger level of finish detail, with larger plans and a more custom-feeling experience than standard subdivision construction.
- Approx. 3,257–4,073 sq. ft.
- Luxury single-family homes
- Ponte Vedra-area pricing and positioning
Iron Branch
Iron Branch sits in Toll Brothers’ upper tier locally, with larger footprints, strong curb appeal, and the kind of room counts buyers expect when they are shopping above the million-dollar mark. If you want a big kitchen, larger secondary bedrooms, and a more dramatic layout, this is one to shortlist.
- Approx. 3,749–4,710 sq. ft.
- Single-family homes
- Built for buyers prioritizing scale, finishes, and presence
Seabrook Village
Seabrook Village gives buyers a way into the Toll Brothers brand with a slightly more compact footprint than the company’s biggest estate-style offerings. The appeal here is efficient luxury: clean design, smart layouts, and access to one of the area’s best-known master-planned settings.
- Approx. 2,609–2,792 sq. ft.
- Single-family homes
- Strong option for buyers who want Nocatee-area access with upgraded finishes
Shores at RiverTown
Shores at RiverTown broadens the lineup with a more approachable price point and a lower-maintenance product type. That makes it appealing to buyers who like Toll Brothers’ design language but want a smaller footprint, simpler upkeep, or a lower total entry price.
- Approx. 1,665–2,394 sq. ft.
- Townhome-style or lower-maintenance plans
- One of the easier entry points into the builder’s local lineup
Toll Brothers at Marsh Harbor
Marsh Harbor is firmly in Toll Brothers’ luxury lane. Homes here are large, polished, and aimed at buyers who want premium architecture, high-end finishes, and a strong Ponte Vedra address. When someone says they want Toll Brothers at the top of the local market, this is the kind of community they usually mean.
- Approx. 3,762–4,795 sq. ft.
- Luxury single-family homes
- Premium pricing with large floor plans and elevated finish expectations
Home Styles & Price Ranges
Across St. Johns County, Toll Brothers currently spans a wider range than many buyers expect. The local lineup starts around the low $500,000s in more compact, lower-maintenance product and rises into the $1.6M to $1.7M range for top-tier Ponte Vedra and Palm Valley opportunities. In practical terms, that means the brand is not just one thing here.
Floor plans in this market run from roughly 1,665 square feet to nearly 4,800 square feet. You will find three- to five-bedroom layouts, first-floor primary suite options, lofts, flex rooms, three-car garages on some plans, and a wide range of outdoor living upgrades. The larger Toll Brothers homes tend to emphasize entertaining spaces, oversized kitchen islands, covered lanais, and more architectural detail in the entry, great room, and owner’s suite.
Design-wise, the builder leans clean and upscale rather than flashy. The appeal is in proportion, finish quality, and personalization. Buyers who want a home that feels more custom without hiring a fully custom builder often land here.
Why Choose Toll Brothers
- Luxury positioning: Toll Brothers is built around the upscale end of the new construction market, with stronger baseline finish expectations than many production competitors.
- Personalization: The design process usually offers more meaningful choices in structure and finishes, which matters if you do not want your home to feel cookie-cutter.
- Recognizable brand: Buyers know the Toll Brothers name, and that reputation can matter when comparing communities and resale appeal later.
- Broad local range: In St. Johns County, the lineup stretches from lower-maintenance options to true luxury single-family homes, so buyers can stay with one builder while comparing different price bands.
The biggest tradeoff is budget discipline. Toll Brothers gives buyers plenty of ways to personalize a home, and those upgrades can move the final number fast. That is where good representation helps.
Working With Josh
Buying new construction through Josh Rogers costs buyers nothing extra. The builder has its own on-site sales team, but that team represents the builder’s interests. Josh represents yours — helping you compare communities, understand what is actually included in the base price, spot upgrade traps before they get expensive, and stay organized from contract to closing.
If Toll Brothers is on your shortlist, bring Josh in before your first serious visit. That gives you a local expert who knows St. Johns County builders, understands how these communities compare, and can help you evaluate whether Toll Brothers is truly the best fit for your goals.
Questions now? Call or text (904) 417-7926 or start here: /work-with-us.
Frequently Asked Questions About Toll Brothers
Is Toll Brothers considered a luxury builder in St. Johns County?
Yes. In the St. Johns County market, Toll Brothers is generally positioned above the typical production builder. Buyers usually come here for stronger architecture, larger floor plans, more finish options, and a more polished design process.
Where is Toll Brothers building in St. Johns County right now?
Current Toll Brothers communities in the county include neighborhoods such as Bartram Ranch, Estuary at Madeira, Haven at Palm Valley, Iron Branch, Seabrook Village, Shores at RiverTown, and Toll Brothers at Marsh Harbor. The exact mix of active and coming-soon communities can change as sections sell out and new releases open.
What price range should I expect for a Toll Brothers home here?
Local starting prices currently range from roughly the low $500,000s to around $1.7 million depending on the neighborhood, floor plan, homesite, and upgrades. Final contract prices can rise meaningfully if you select premium lots or extensive design studio upgrades.
Can I personalize a Toll Brothers home?
Usually, yes. Toll Brothers is known for giving buyers more say in structural options, cabinetry, countertops, flooring, lighting, and other finish selections than many production builders. The exact menu depends on the community and whether you are buying from the ground up or choosing a quick move-in home.
Do I need my own Realtor when visiting a Toll Brothers model?
Yes, and it does not cost you extra. Having your own representation gives you someone focused on your side of the contract, your lot selection, and your budget — especially helpful when comparing upgrade packages and builder incentives.
Interested in a Toll Brothers home? Let’s talk.
If you are weighing Toll Brothers against other St. Johns County builders, Josh can help you compare neighborhoods, pricing, incentives, and what you actually get for the money before you sign anything.
Work With UsExplore Toll Brothers Communities
If you are comparing builders, these community pages make it easier to see where this builder fits in the market.