Everything You Need to Know About Moving to St. Johns County — From Someone Who Actually Lives Here

Straight answers from a local expert who's helped over 1,500 buyers relocate to St. Johns County.

Trusted by relocation buyers across St. Johns County

Google Reviews

What relocation buyers say about working with Josh and the F3 Home Team

Real social proof matters when you're moving from out of state. Here are a few standout experiences from buyers who trusted the team to guide their move.

★★★★★
“Moving from New Jersey, we had no idea where to start. Josh and his team made the entire process stress-free. They knew every community inside and out.”
Michael T.
Nocatee
★★★★★
“Incredible knowledge of St. Johns County. We looked at 6 communities and they helped us narrow it down to the perfect fit for our family. Highly recommend.”
Sarah K.
RiverTown
★★★★★
“We were relocating from California and couldn't visit in person. Josh's team handled everything remotely. Closed in 30 days. Beyond impressed.”
David L.
Shearwater
Why This Site Exists

Most real estate websites show you houses. This one answers your questions.

Including the ones most agents won't touch. How much do CDD fees really cost? Which areas have the highest school ratings? What are the real trade-offs between communities? We answer all of it — honestly, completely, and without the sales pitch.

Josh Rogers
St. Johns County Real Estate Expert
What Does It Cost?

How Much Does It Really Cost to Live in St. Johns County?

Most real estate sites hide the numbers. We don't.

Home Prices

$300K – $3M+

Depending on community, size, and whether it's new construction or resale.

CDD Fees

$900 – $4,500/yr

Community Development District fees vary significantly by neighborhood. We break it all down.

Cost of Living

Below National Avg

No state income tax, strong schools, and growing infrastructure make SJC a smart long-term move.

Find Your Fit

Not Sure Which Community Fits Your Priorities? Start Here.

We've done the side-by-side comparisons so you don't have to.

Nocatee vs. SilverLeaf

Both are master-planned and family-focused — but they're very different in price, CDD fees, and lifestyle. Here's the honest breakdown.

Compare →

RiverTown vs. Shearwater

Two of the most amenity-rich communities in St. Johns County. Which one is actually worth the CDD fees?

Compare →

St. Johns County vs. St. Augustine

Same general area, very different lifestyle. Which side of the county fits where you're headed?

Compare →

New Construction vs. Resale

New construction sounds appealing — but is it actually the better buy right now? We break down both sides.

Compare →
Ranked #1 in Florida

Why St. Johns County's School Ratings Are a Top Reason People Relocate Here

St. Johns County is consistently ranked the #1 school district in Florida. Here's what that means for your decision.

#1 Ranked School District in Florida
A-Rated District-Wide Rating
25+ A-Rated Schools in the District

From Ponte Vedra to Nocatee to World Golf Village, St. Johns County schools consistently rank among the highest in the state. District performance data, school-by-school ratings, and what each area's school zone actually means for your decision — it's all in our Schools Guide.

YOUR QUESTIONS, ANSWERED

Your Questions, Answered Honestly

St. Johns County offers top-ranked schools, low crime rates, and rapid growth — but that growth brings traffic, rising home prices, and CDD fees that catch many buyers off guard. We cover all of it honestly in our full guide.

CDD fees range from $900 to $4,500 per year depending on the community. They cover amenities, roads, and infrastructure — but whether they're worth it depends on what the community offers and how long you plan to stay.

Nocatee consistently scores high on both. That said, RiverTown, Shearwater, and SilverLeaf are all strong contenders depending on your priorities.

It depends on your timeline, budget, and priorities. New construction offers customization and builder incentives. Resale can offer better value in established neighborhoods. We break down both in our buyer guides.

Most of St. Johns County is 20–40 minutes from the Atlantic coast. Ponte Vedra Beach is within the county. Jacksonville Beach and St. Augustine Beach are both easily accessible.

Traffic has grown significantly as the county has expanded. Morning and evening commutes into Jacksonville can be congested — particularly on CR-210 and US-1. Many residents build this into their community decision.

Yes — Durbin Crossing, Aberdeen, and parts of Fruit Cove still have resale inventory under $400K. New construction under $400K is increasingly rare but not impossible.

Nocatee is the right fit if you want resort-style amenities and top schools and are comfortable with CDD fees. If you want more space, lower fees, or a quieter lifestyle, RiverTown, Trailmark, or Shearwater may be a better match.

Have a question we didn't answer?

Ask Josh Directly →
BUYERS WHO MADE THE MOVE

Hear From People Who've Done It

Real stories from real buyers who relocated to St. Johns County.

Relocated from Northern Virginia
Now in Nocatee

We looked at communities all over Florida for two years. The St. Johns with Josh team knew every neighborhood inside and out — they helped us narrow it down in one weekend visit.

— Michael & Sarah T.

Relocated from New York
Now in RiverTown

We bought remotely without ever seeing the house in person. That sounds terrifying, but Josh's team made it seamless. Closed in 28 days. We couldn't be happier.

— David L.

Relocated from California
Now in Shearwater

We had a very specific list of priorities. Instead of just showing us houses, they showed us which communities actually matched what we were looking for. Night and day from every other agent we talked to.

— Jennifer K.

* Placeholder stories — real client testimonials coming soon.

HEAR IT FROM JOSH

Hear It Straight From Someone Who Knows This Market

Not a sales pitch. Just an honest overview of what makes St. Johns County different — and whether it might be the right fit for you.

Watch Josh's Latest Video

Watch Josh's Latest Video

Latest From the Blog

Thinking of Moving to St. Johns County?

Tell us what you need, where you're moving from, and your timeline. We'll help you build a smart next step.