Moving from Texas to St. Johns County — What to Expect
By Josh Rogers
Quick Answer: Texas-to-Florida moves are less common than Northeast-to-Florida moves, but they happen more than people realize — and the motivations are often different. Texas buyers moving to St. Johns County are usually driven by lifestyle factors more than taxes: milder summers, Atlantic coast proximity, Florida’s specific school district, or a desire to be closer to East Coast connections. Here’s what to expect.
Why Texans Move to Florida
This one surprises people. Texas and Florida are both high-growth Sun Belt states with no state income tax, warm climates, and large master-planned communities. So why would a Texan choose Florida?
The answer varies. Here are the most common reasons I encounter:
Climate. Surprisingly, Florida’s climate can be more appealing to some Texas buyers. Texas summers — particularly in Dallas-Fort Worth, Houston, and San Antonio — are extreme: intense heat with less humidity in some regions, brutal humid heat in Houston. Florida’s summers are comparable in intensity but shorter, and the fall-through-spring period is consistently beautiful in a way that Texas’ variable winters don’t always match.
Atlantic Coast access. Florida’s beaches — particularly northeast Florida’s uncrowded, less commercialized stretches — offer ocean access that Texas’ Gulf Coast doesn’t replicate.
School district quality. St. Johns County School District has a national reputation. Texas has excellent school districts, but some buyers specifically seek out St. Johns County’s ranking.
Career relocation. Jacksonville’s growing employer base has attracted transfers from Texas-based companies.
Proximity to relatives. For Texans with relatives in the Southeast or Mid-Atlantic, Florida positions them more centrally to East Coast connections.
The Financial Picture: Texas vs. Florida
The financial comparison between Texas and Florida is the most nuanced of any state comparison.
State Income Tax
Both Texas and Florida have no state income tax. This is a wash from a relocation-motivation standpoint.
Property Taxes
Here the picture diverges significantly — in Florida’s favor.
Texas property taxes are famously high. In the Dallas, Houston, and Austin metro areas, effective property tax rates of 1.8%–2.8% are common. On a $500,000 home in Texas, you might pay $9,000–$14,000 per year in property taxes.
Florida’s effective rates in St. Johns County typically run 1.0%–1.4%. On a $500,000 home, that’s $5,000–$7,000. The Homestead Exemption reduces it further for primary residents.
For buyers coming from the Houston or Austin suburbs, this is often the most financially significant aspect of the move.
Be aware: CDD fees in master-planned communities add to the tax bill. Verify exact amounts with the St. Johns County Tax Collector before making an offer.
Home Prices
Texas home prices have increased significantly in recent years. The premium markets in Austin have approached or exceeded St. Johns County price points. In Dallas, Houston, and San Antonio, depending on the suburb, comparable housing may be more or less expensive than St. Johns County. This comparison requires case-by-case analysis.
Climate: Texas vs. Florida
Both are hot. Both are humid in some areas. The comparison is worth breaking down.
Texas Summers
Dallas summers bring dry heat and temperatures regularly exceeding 100°F. Houston summers bring intense heat with Gulf humidity. Both are demanding.
Florida Summers
St. Johns County summers are hot and humid — typically in the high 80s to low 90s with high humidity. More moderate in peak temperature than Dallas but more humid. Generally comparable to Houston in feel.
The difference: Florida’s “hot season” is roughly June through September. Dallas’ extends from late May through October. Northeast Florida has a shorter period of peak discomfort.
Hurricanes vs. Tornadoes
Texas is significantly more prone to tornadoes than Florida. Florida’s primary severe weather risk is hurricanes, which are more predictable and provide more warning time. For buyers from Texas tornado country, this is often a psychological trade-up: hurricane preparedness is stressful but plannable; tornado warnings are sudden.
St. Johns County’s northeast Florida location reduces hurricane frequency and intensity relative to the Gulf Coast.
Lifestyle Differences
Scale of Communities
Texas is famous for scale — everything bigger, including its cities. Jacksonville is smaller than Houston, Dallas, or San Antonio. St. Johns County is a quieter, more suburban environment than any major Texas metro.
For buyers coming from the Dallas or Houston suburbs, the adjustment is mild. For buyers coming from dense Texas urban cores, it’s more significant.
Outdoor Recreation
Both Texas and Florida offer significant outdoor recreation, but the activities are different. Florida’s natural focus is water-based: kayaking, paddleboarding, fishing, beach access. Texas offers more varied terrain — hill country, prairies, the Hill Country rivers. If you’re a Texas hill country person, you’re giving something up. If you’re a water person, Florida may actually offer more.
Community Character
St. Johns County’s master-planned communities have a strong community culture. Texas has similar communities — The Woodlands, Katy, Frisco — so this isn’t a foreign concept for many Texas buyers.
Schools
St. Johns County School District competes with Texas’ best suburban districts — Frisco ISD, Katy ISD, Southlake Carroll ISD. Both states have excellent suburban school districts, and this comparison is genuinely close. The key difference is that St. Johns County’s entire district ranks highly, whereas in Texas, quality varies significantly by district.
School zones in St. Johns County are subject to change due to rapid growth. Always verify your specific address with the St. Johns County School District at stjohns.k12.fl.us/zoning/ before purchasing.
What Texas Buyers Often Miss About Florida
The social rebuild is still required. Texas has strong community culture and a particularly warm, welcoming social environment. Moving to St. Johns County still requires intentional community-building — it doesn’t happen automatically.
The beach is closer than most Texas beach options. Atlantic beaches are 20-40 minutes from most of St. Johns County. Galveston from Houston is comparable. But northeast Florida’s beaches are significantly less crowded and more accessible in feel than Houston or DFW beach access.
Seafood is exceptional. Florida’s Gulf and Atlantic seafood is genuinely spectacular. If you’re a Texas Gulf Coast seafood person, you’ll feel right at home.
The Bottom Line
Texas to St. Johns County is a lifestyle-driven move more than a financially-driven one. For Texans who want milder summers (in length if not intensity), Atlantic coast access, strong school district ranking, and lower property taxes, the move makes real sense.
The financial comparison is favorable on property taxes and comparable on other metrics. The lifestyle trade-off involves exchanging Texas’ specific culture and scale for Florida’s more relaxed community orientation.
If you’re considering this and want a real conversation about whether St. Johns County fits your priorities, reach out at StJohnsWithJosh.com/contact.
================================================================================