Florida has no state income tax — that’s the headline most buyers from high-tax states already know. But property taxes are real, the system works differently than most out-of-state buyers expect, and the gap between what a current homeowner pays and what you’ll pay as the new buyer can be significant. Josh Rogers at F3 Home Team has walked hundreds of relocating buyers through exactly this calculation — from the Save Our Homes cap and homestead exemption to CDD fees and portability. This guide covers everything you need to know before you budget for a St. Johns County purchase.

Table of Contents

How Does Florida’s Property Tax System Differ From What You’re Used To?

The first thing most buyers from New Jersey, New York, Connecticut, Massachusetts, or California notice about Florida’s tax picture is the absence of state income tax. That’s real and it’s significant — for buyers who’ve been paying 6–13% in state income taxes for decades, the financial impact of eliminating that expense is not a rounding error. It compounds meaningfully over time and changes the math on retirement planning, salary negotiations, and overall household budget.

But property taxes in Florida are real and worth understanding before you finalize any purchase budget. Here’s how the system works at the structural level:

Florida property taxes are based on assessed value multiplied by a millage rate. The millage rate is expressed in mills — one mill equals $1 per $1,000 of assessed value. St. Johns County’s millage rate is competitive with other Florida counties and substantially lower than what most buyers from high-tax states are accustomed to. The overall tax burden picture for buyers relocating from the Northeast or California is genuinely favorable.

What makes Florida’s system distinctive — and what catches most out-of-state buyers off guard — are the protections available to homesteaded residents. The Save Our Homes cap limits assessed value increases to 3% per year for homesteaded properties. Over time, this creates a significant divergence between assessed value and market value for long-term homeowners. And when that home sells, the new buyer doesn’t inherit those protections — they start fresh at the purchase price.

“The most common confusion I see with buyers coming from the Northeast is they look at the property tax estimate in the listing and assume that’s what they’ll pay. It almost never is — especially when the seller has owned for 10 or 15 years under homestead protection. I run the new-buyer projection for every home a buyer I’m working with is seriously considering, because that’s the number that has to fit the budget.”

— Josh Rogers, F3 Home Team

What Happens to Your Tax Bill When You Buy in St. Johns County?

When you purchase a home in Florida, the property’s assessed value resets to the purchase price. This is called the assessment reset, and it’s one of the most important things out-of-state buyers need to understand before finalizing any budget.

Here’s why it matters in practice: A homeowner who purchased in St. Johns County 15 years ago, established homestead exemption, and has been protected by the Save Our Homes cap may be paying property taxes based on an assessed value that is 30–50% below current market value. Their annual tax bill reflects that lower assessed value — not what the home is worth today.

When you buy that home, the county reassesses the property at your purchase price. The Save Our Homes cap resets for you. The tax bill shown in the listing — the number that appeared in public records and may appear on Zillow — is what the previous owner paid. Your bill will likely be substantially higher, sometimes significantly so.

The good news: you’re not locked into that higher rate permanently. Once you homestead the property as your primary Florida residence, your assessed value is capped going forward at 3% per year, and you begin accumulating the same protection the prior owner had built up. But you start from zero, which means the first few years after purchase represent the highest tax exposure you’ll have on that specific home.

Buyers I work with sometimes ask whether they should negotiate the purchase price to account for the tax increase. The short answer is: the seller’s tax bill is irrelevant to what you’ll pay as the buyer. What matters is your purchase price and the projected millage rate. I calculate that projected new-buyer tax figure for any home we’re seriously considering.

Tax Factor What the Listing Shows What You’ll Actually Pay
Assessed Value Prior owner’s (often well below market) Your purchase price (reset)
Save Our Homes Cap Accumulated for prior owner Resets — you start fresh
Homestead Exemption Prior owner’s (if applicable) You apply separately — takes effect next year
CDD Assessment May or may not be included Verify separately for specific parcel

How Does Florida Homestead Exemption Reduce Your Property Taxes?

Florida’s homestead exemption is one of the most significant tax benefits available to property owners who establish the state as their primary residence. Here’s exactly how it works:

The $25,000 exemption: Florida provides a $25,000 exemption from assessed value that applies to all taxing authorities. This directly reduces the taxable value of your home and lowers your overall tax bill.

The additional $25,000 exemption: There’s a second $25,000 exemption that applies to assessed values between $50,000 and $75,000. This additional exemption applies to all taxing authorities except school taxes. Combined, the two exemptions can provide meaningful annual savings.

Save Our Homes cap: Once homestead is established, Florida’s Save Our Homes amendment caps annual increases in assessed value at 3% or the rate of inflation, whichever is lower. Over time, this protection becomes increasingly valuable as market values appreciate — your tax bill can’t grow at the same rate as market value.

To receive homestead exemption, the property must be your primary Florida residence as of January 1st of the tax year. You apply through the St. Johns County Property Appraiser’s office by March 1st to receive the exemption for that year’s tax bill.

This means: if you close on your home in April, your first full tax bill as the new owner will reflect the full purchase price assessment without homestead protection. You apply for homestead the following January–March period, and it takes effect on the following year’s bill. Plan for that first year’s higher tax exposure in your budget.

One more important detail: homestead exemption doesn’t happen automatically. You have to apply. It’s not complicated, but buyers who miss the March 1st deadline lose the exemption for that tax year entirely. I remind every buyer I work with to calendar the application deadline as part of their post-closing checklist.

What Is Property Tax Portability and Does It Apply to You?

Florida’s portability provision is one of the more valuable and underutilized benefits in the state’s property tax system — and it specifically applies to buyers who are already Florida homeowners moving to St. Johns County from elsewhere in the state.

Here’s how portability works: When a long-term Florida homeowner sells their homesteaded property, they’ve accumulated a Save Our Homes benefit — the gap between their assessed value and the market value of the home. Under portability, they can transfer some or all of that benefit to a new homesteaded property purchased within three years of leaving their prior home.

The amount of benefit you can port depends on the difference between your prior home’s assessed value and its market value, and the value relationship between your old home and new home. The calculation has some nuance, but the result can be meaningful — it reduces the assessed value on your new St. Johns County home, which reduces your annual tax bill.

If this applies to your situation — you’re currently a Florida homeowner selling to move to St. Johns County — it’s worth calculating the portability benefit before you close. I work with buyers on this analysis as part of the full cost-of-ownership picture. The three-year window means you shouldn’t wait to explore it if you’ve already sold your prior home.

Portability does not apply to buyers moving from out of state. If you’re relocating from New Jersey, New York, or California, you start fresh in Florida’s homestead system — which still provides significant long-term protection, just without the portability head start.

How Do CDD Fees Factor Into Your St. Johns County Property Tax Bill?

This is one of the most important pieces of the property tax conversation for buyers in St. Johns County, and it’s frequently misunderstood — including by buyers who have done significant research.

In communities with a Community Development District — which includes Nocatee, RiverTown, Shearwater, Beacon Lake, Beachwalk, Julington Creek Plantation, Durbin Crossing, and others — the CDD assessment appears as a separate line item on your property tax bill. It is not a property tax in the traditional sense. It’s the repayment of bonds used to finance the community’s infrastructure. But it is a real, required annual payment that appears alongside your standard property tax calculation.

This matters for three practical reasons:

First: Tax estimates shown in listings or on real estate portals may or may not include the CDD line. When buyers see a property tax figure and ask whether it includes CDD, the answer isn’t always clear from the listing. Always ask — and always verify with a separate CDD disclosure for the specific parcel.

Second: The CDD amount varies by parcel and phase within the same community. Two homes in the same neighborhood of Nocatee can have meaningfully different CDD assessments depending on lot size, location, and which phase of development they’re in. There’s no single “Nocatee CDD fee” — it’s specific to the parcel.

Third: The CDD fee is not affected by homestead exemption. Your homestead exemption reduces your ad valorem (assessed value-based) taxes, but the CDD assessment is a separate obligation that runs with the land regardless of ownership or homestead status.

Silverleaf is an important comparison point here: it’s a master-planned community that does not carry a CDD structure. Buyers comparing Silverleaf to Nocatee on price need to factor this in — the absence of a CDD assessment in Silverleaf can represent meaningful annual savings that partially or fully offset any purchase price difference.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Florida really have no state income tax?

Yes — Florida has no personal state income tax. This is established in the Florida Constitution and has been in place for decades. For buyers relocating from states like New Jersey (10.75% top rate), California (13.3% top rate), or New York (up to 10.9%), the elimination of state income tax is one of the most financially significant aspects of the move. It’s not a small or temporary benefit — it compounds over years and significantly affects retirement and long-term financial planning.

How much will my property taxes increase when I buy a home in St. Johns County?

The answer is specific to the home you’re purchasing and cannot be reliably estimated from the listing’s tax figure. The key variables are your purchase price (which becomes the new assessed value), the applicable millage rate for that property’s location, and whether the home is in a CDD community (which adds a separate assessment). For homes where the seller has owned for many years under homestead and Save Our Homes protection, the gap between their current tax bill and your projected new-buyer bill can be substantial — sometimes thousands of dollars per year. I run this projection for every buyer I work with before they finalize a budget.

When should I apply for Florida homestead exemption?

You apply through the St. Johns County Property Appraiser’s office by March 1st for the exemption to apply to that year’s tax bill. The property must be your primary Florida residence as of January 1st of the tax year. If you close on your home after January 1st, you apply the following January–March for the next year’s exemption. Don’t miss the deadline — there’s no grace period, and missing it means waiting a full year for the exemption to take effect. Add it to your post-closing calendar as soon as you close.

What is the Save Our Homes cap and how does it protect me?

The Save Our Homes amendment to the Florida Constitution limits annual increases in the assessed value of a homesteaded property to 3% or the rate of inflation, whichever is lower. This means that even as market values rise significantly, your taxable assessed value can only increase by a maximum of 3% per year. Over time, this creates meaningful and growing protection against property tax increases — which is one of the reasons long-term Florida homeowners often pay taxes on assessed values well below market value. You activate this protection by filing for homestead exemption.

Can I transfer my Save Our Homes benefit from my current Florida home to a new one in St. Johns County?

Yes — Florida’s portability provision allows you to transfer your accumulated Save Our Homes benefit to a new homesteaded property within three years of selling your prior home. The amount you can port depends on the difference between your prior home’s assessed and market values and the value relationship between the homes. This can meaningfully reduce your assessed value on the new property. If you’re currently a Florida homeowner selling to move to St. Johns County, calculating your portability benefit should be part of your pre-purchase financial planning.

How do I find out what the CDD fee is for a specific home?

The CDD assessment for a specific parcel is disclosed in the CDD disclosure document — a required disclosure in Florida real estate transactions for properties in CDD communities. The amount varies by parcel, so the only accurate way to know the figure for a specific home is to pull that disclosure. When I work with buyers evaluating homes in CDD communities like Nocatee, RiverTown, or Shearwater, I pull the CDD disclosure for each property they’re seriously considering so the annual assessment is factored into the budget before any offer is made.

Have questions about the real tax picture for a specific home or community in St. Johns County? Reach out at StJohnsWithJosh.com/contact — I’ll walk you through the full cost-of-ownership calculation so you know the real numbers before you commit.

If you want help thinking through the tradeoffs in this article, Josh Rogers with the F3 Home Team can help. Contact Josh Rogers.

Josh Rogers leads F3 Home Team — the #1 team in Jacksonville by sales volume (RealTrends) for 3 consecutive years, and #1 in all of Northeast Florida (Jacksonville & St. Johns County) in 2026. Based in St. Johns County, FL, F3 Home Team has helped over 1,500 buyers and sellers since 2016 find the right home — from relocation buyers moving from out of state to local homeowners upgrading into their forever neighborhood. If you have questions about buying in St. Johns County, reach out at StJohnsWithJosh.com.

Josh Rogers, REALTOR® with F3 Home Team at Real Broker is the founder of StJohnsWithJosh.com. Josh Rogers and the F3 Home Team have helped over 1,500 buyers and sellers since 2016, and his goal is simple: give you the honest, practical information you need to make the right decision.

Thinking of Moving to St. John's County?

Josh and the F3 Home Team are here to help.

Let's Talk